Umbrella, sole trader and personal limited company structures produce different tax, PRSI, expense and compliance outcomes. There is no universal day-rate threshold that makes one option right for every contractor. Forti compares the options using your contract, expected billings, working pattern and plans.
The right answer depends on the full position — contract, billings, personal cash needs, expenses and plans. A limited company can create more options, but it also creates annual accounting costs and director responsibilities.
Day rate matters, but it is not the only figure. A reliable comparison needs all of these.
A contract cannot simply label someone self-employed. Revenue expects the engaging business to apply the Supreme Court's Karshan five-step framework to the facts of each working relationship.
The umbrella employs you, invoices the agency or client, runs payroll and pays your net salary. Lower administration — but you do not control a separate company or retain profit inside one.
A personal limited company gives you control of invoicing, business banking and the timing of company decisions. It also creates company-law, payroll, tax and bookkeeping duties.
A director who owns or controls 50% or more of the company is classified as self-employed for PRSI and pays Class S. The position below 50% is not decided by one automatic rule.
PSWT is a 20% withholding tax deducted by accountable persons — government departments, local authorities, the HSE, authorised health insurers and many state or semi-state bodies — from payments for certain professional services.
The main Irish VAT registration threshold for services is €42,500. The threshold is not the only test — cross-border services, overseas clients and non-Irish establishments can create separate obligations.
The structure changes the legal test, but it does not remove the need for a genuine business purpose. Private spending remains private regardless of the company structure.
Most owner-managed contractor companies are close companies. The surcharge should be reviewed before profits are left in the company for long periods.
From the initial structure review through to year-end compliance — and revisited when your circumstances change.
The structure review is always free. Ongoing accounting follows the LTD plans for limited-company contractors. Umbrella and complex work is confirmed after review.
Irish company formation from €295 + VAT where a limited company is the chosen route. All fees exclude VAT at 23%.
The best contractor structure is the one that matches the real working arrangement and the numbers. Forti gives you the comparison first, then manages the accounting route you choose.
Get a free contractor structure review